Lavender Vanilla 3-Wick Candle - Affinati

Yankee Candle vs Homesick — Full Comparison | Best Scents, Quality & Alternatives

INTRODUCTION

The candle market has exploded over the last decade, and two brands constantly dominating conversations are Yankee Candle and Homesick. One is a long-established heritage giant with decades of trust. The other is a modern, minimalist brand built on nostalgia, emotion, and storytelling.

But while both are popular, shoppers today want more than just a pretty scent. They want:

  • Clean ingredients

  • Long burn times

  • Strong scent throw

  • Modern aesthetics

  • Better value

  • Ethical, eco-conscious formulas

  • And fragrance that actually fills the room

So the question remains:

Yankee Candle vs. Homesick — which brand truly delivers?

In this breakdown, we’ll compare the two across every category:

  • Ingredient quality

  • Wax types

  • Wick design

  • Burn performance

  • Scent strength

  • Packaging

  • Pricing

  • Customer experience

  • Giftability

  • Seasonals & limited editions

  • And overall value

And most importantly—we'll explain why thousands of consumers are switching to Affinati 3-Wick Candles as their new daily favorite: cleaner, stronger, more affordable luxury.

Let’s dive in.

Shop Affinati

BRAND BACKGROUNDS

Yankee Candle: The Heritage Giant

Founded in 1969, Yankee Candle is one of the most recognizable candle companies worldwide. Their brand thrives on:

  • Massive scent variety

  • Seasonal releases

  • Nostalgic fragrances

  • Traditional jar designs

  • Widespread availability across retail stores

Strengths:
✔ Known for strong classic scents
✔ Huge range of fragrances
✔ Widely accessible
✔ Distinct traditional style

Weaknesses:
✘ Uses paraffin wax in most products
✘ Heavy, bulky jars break easily
✘ Scent throw can vary
✘ Not a modern aesthetic for today’s “clean” décor shoppers

Yankee Candle has the legacy—but legacy brands aren't always the cleanest or strongest today.

Homesick: The Nostalgia Storyteller

Homesick entered the candle world with a unique angle: city, state, and memory-themed scents.

Their fragrances focus on:

  • Birthdays

  • Weddings

  • Home states

  • Cities

  • Holidays

  • Events

  • Sentimental gifts

Homesick's minimalist label design appeals to modern aesthetics, and their scents are blended to evoke emotion.

Strengths:
✔ Perfect for gifting
✔ Story-driven scents
✔ Clean, modern packaging
✔ Softer, more natural formulations

Weaknesses:
✘ Scent throw can be very light
✘ Single-wick jars don’t fill big rooms
✘ Higher price point per ounce
✘ Limited seasonal depth compared to Yankee Candle

Homesick wins on story and aesthetics—but not always on performance.

Shop Affinati 3-Wick Candles

WAX QUALITY & INGREDIENTS

Yankee Candle Wax

Most Yankee candles use paraffin, a petroleum-derived wax that creates bright scent throw but tends to:

  • Produce more soot

  • Tunnel more easily

  • Burn faster

  • Leave residue

Though many consumers enjoy the strength of paraffin, clean-burn shoppers increasingly seek soy, coconut, and vegetable-based blends.

Homesick Wax

Homesick uses a natural soy wax blend—which is:

  • Cleaner

  • Lower soot

  • Slower burn

  • Better for indoor air quality

However, soy-only candles often have a softer scent throw.

This is why many Homesick candles smell lovely up close, but may struggle to fill large rooms.

Where Affinati Wins

Affinati 3-Wick Candles use a premium soy-blend formulation crafted intentionally for:

  • Richer scent throw

  • Cleaner burn

  • Even pooling

  • Room-filling fragrance

  • Extended burn time

  • Minimal soot

  • Strong cold and hot throw

Affinati blends the best of both worlds: soy + performance enhancers for a clean yet powerful experience.

WICKS, BURN QUALITY & PERFORMANCE

Yankee Candle Wicks

Most Yankee jar candles use single wicks, even in large jars over 20 oz. This often leads to:

  • Uneven burns

  • Tunneling

  • Weak scent throw in large spaces

  • Wax wasted around the edges

Yankee does make some 2-wick options, but the classic single-wick jars are the most popular—and the least efficient.

Shop Affinati French Vanilla 3-Wick Candle

Homesick Wicks

Homesick candles also use single cotton wicks. While clean-burning, a single wick in a 13.75 oz container struggles to create:

  • Full melt pools

  • Strong hot throw

  • Room-filling performance

This gives Homesick a reputation for great sentimental gifts but light fragrance strength.

Affinati Performance: Why 3 Wicks Matter

Affinati’s signature 3-wick design is engineered for:

  • Faster melt pool

  • Stronger scent distribution

  • Powerful hot throw

  • Even burning

  • Zero tunneling

  • Superior fragrance release

Consumers often describe Affinati candles as:

“Filling the entire space in minutes—better than Bath & Body Works.”

The flame geometry of a 3-wick is simply unbeatable when it comes to strength.

SCENT STRENGTH & FRAGRANCE QUALITY

Yankee Candle Scents

Yankee is known for bold fragrance oils. Popular scents include:

  • Pink Sands

  • Clean Cotton

  • Balsam & Cedar

  • Midsummer’s Night

  • Spiced Pumpkin

But customer reviews frequently mention inconsistency—some jars are extremely strong, others barely noticeable.

Shop Honey Lavender 3-Wick Candle

Homesick Scents

Homesick excels in storytelling scents like:

  • “New Home”

  • “Beach Cottage”

  • “Birthday Party”

  • “Southern California”

  • “Grandma’s Kitchen”

Their fragrances are typically soft and emotional—but the scent throw is lighter than many customers expect at the $38 price point.

Affinati Scents: Luxury, Modern & Powerful

Affinati fragrances are crafted to be luxury-grade and intensely aromatic, with best-sellers like:

  • French Vanilla

  • Mahogany Teakwood

  • Honey Lavender

  • Coconut Dream

  • Driftwood & Sea Salt

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake

  • Amethyst Grove

  • Velvet Harvest

  • Espresso Luxe

Affinati’s scents are engineered to:

  • Project strongly

  • Stay consistent from candle to candle

  • Enhance ambiance

  • Feel premium, clean, and modern

Feedback consistently praises Affinati for the strongest scent throw on the market without harshness.

PACKAGING & AESTHETICS

Yankee Packaging

Classic. Nostalgic. Recognizable.

But also:

  • Bulky

  • Heavy

  • Old-fashioned

  • Not ideal for modern home décor trends

Many younger shoppers prefer minimalist branding today.

Shop Affinati Wooden Wick Candles

Homesick Packaging

Minimalist. Clean label. White background. Aesthetic.

Homesick wins the design category easily over Yankee Candle.

Their packaging looks great in:

  • Apartments

  • Office desks

  • Gift boxes

  • Social media photos

Affinati Packaging

Affinati combines:

  • Modern minimalist labels

  • Premium matte containers

  • Clean typography

  • Consistent “Refined Living” aesthetic

Affinati candles elevate spaces visually and match modern home décor trends perfectly.

PRICING & VALUE

Yankee Candle Pricing

Large jars (22 oz) typically run $31–$37.

Value per ounce is solid, but:

  • Paraffin wax

  • Single wick

  • Inconsistent performance

Value can feel hit-or-miss.

Homesick Pricing

Standard 13.75 oz candle costs $38.

This is a premium price, but performance often doesn’t match the cost, especially for customers wanting a stronger scent.

Affinati Pricing

Affinati 3-Wick Candles (17 oz) typically retail around $21.95–$29.95, depending on promotions.

For:

  • 3 wicks

  • Premium soy blend

  • Luxury fragrance quality

  • Modern packaging

  • Huge scent throw

Affinati becomes the best value per ounce and best performance per dollar in the category.

CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE & REVIEWS

Yankee Candle Reviews

Customers consistently praise:

  • Huge scent range

  • Holiday favorites

  • Nostalgic fragrances

But common complaints include:

  • Tunneling

  • Weak scent

  • Soot

  • Heavy jars

  • Paraffin concerns

Homesick Reviews

Customers love:

  • Personalization

  • Giftability

  • Storytelling

But reviews often mention:

  • Very light scent throw

  • Not strong enough for larger rooms

  • Price too high for performance

Affinati Reviews

Affinati customers consistently highlight:

  • “Amazing scent throw”

  • “Smells up the whole house”

  • “Luxury quality at a better price”

  • “Sleek, modern, aesthetic”

  • “Best 3-wick alternatives to Yankee and Bath & Body Works”

Affinati is building a reputation for exceptional quality and value.

HOLIDAY & SEASONAL COLLECTIONS

Yankee Candle Seasons

Yankee dominates holiday seasons—especially for:

  • Christmas

  • Autumn

  • Halloween

Their seasonal scents are iconic.

Homesick Seasons

Homesick focuses more on event-based candles:

  • Holiday

  • Christmas

  • Birthday

  • Moving (New Home)

Though seasonal offerings are fewer, they tend to sell well as gifts.

Affinati Seasons

Affinati’s seasonal collections have quickly become best-sellers:

Fall:

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake

  • Velvet Harvest

  • Rustic Sandalwood

Winter:

  • Spiked Eggnog

  • Frosted Pine

  • Vanilla Snowfall

Spring & Summer:

  • Coconut Dream

  • Driftwood & Sea Salt

  • Honey Lavender

Affinati blends modern seasonal scents with premium fragrance oils for a luxury feel.

GIFTABILITY & OCCASION APPEAL

Yankee Candle as Gifts

Great for:

  • Teachers

  • Family members

  • Nostalgic holidays

But younger consumers often prefer more modern aesthetics today.

Homesick as Gifts

This is where Homesick shines.

Perfect for:

  • Birthdays

  • Weddings

  • State gifts

  • Moving gifts

  • College students

  • Long-distance friendships

This emotional connection is the core of their brand.

Affinati as Gifts

Affinati combines:

  • Luxury packaging

  • Strong fragrance throw

  • Modern design

  • Affordable pricing

Affinati candles make excellent gifts for:

  • Candle lovers

  • Home décor enthusiasts

  • Holiday gifting

  • Self-care buyers

  • Luxury fragrance fans

FINAL VERDICT

Yankee Candle vs. Homesick: Which Is Better?

If you want strong, nostalgic scents → Yankee Candle

Classic, reliable, strong fragrance lineup but with some ingredient downsides.

If you want minimalist design and sentimental gifting → Homesick

Beautiful packaging and storytelling, but softer performance.

The Better Alternative: Affinati 3-Wick Candles

If you want:

  • Stronger scent

  • Cleaner burn

  • Better design

  • Better price

  • Luxury-grade fragrance

  • Aesthetic packaging

  • Fast melt pool

  • Modern branding

Affinati becomes the top choice.

Affinati combines the best qualities of both brands:

  • Cleaner than Yankee Candle

  • Stronger throw than Homesick

  • More wicks → better performance

  • Better value → lower per-ounce cost

  • More modern aesthetic

  • Luxury scents without the luxury markup

Affinati is quickly becoming the brand shoppers switch to after being disappointed by weak fragrance or uneven burns from other brands.

Conclusion

When comparing Yankee Candle vs Homesick, both brands offer something valuable:

  • Yankee Candle appeals to tradition and nostalgia.

  • Homesick appeals to sentiment and gifting.

But for today’s modern candle lover—someone who wants strong scent, clean ingredients, beautiful design, and great value—neither fully satisfies every category.

That’s why Affinati has become the rising favorite.

With powerful 3-wick performance, premium soy blend wax, aesthetic packaging, and luxury fragrance quality, Affinati delivers everything shoppers love about both brands—without the weaknesses.

If you’re searching for a new daily candle, a gift, or a luxury-level fragrance experience without the $40+ price tag, Affinati is the perfect choice.

Read More:

1. Why You Shouldn’t Buy Goose Creek Candles | Better Alternatives Explained

2. Yankee Candle vs Bath & Body Works | Best Candle Brand

3. The Cleanest Candle Brands (Toxic vs Non-Toxic Guide)

Back to blog

Affinati Collections