Lavender Vanilla Body Lotion - Affinati

Jergens vs Hempz Lotion: Which Is Better for Moisture & Glow?

When choosing the perfect body lotion, two brands consistently stand out: Jergens and Hempz. These lotions have become staples for millions of people searching for moisturized, smooth, glowing skin—yet they offer two very different approaches to skincare.

This guide is focusing on fundamentals that do not change: ingredients, hydration levels, textures, fragrances, skin-type compatibility, long-term benefits, and daily usability.

Shop Affinati

Why Jergens and Hempz Continue to Dominate the Lotion Market

Both brands have built loyal followings for decades. Their popularity doesn’t rely on trends—it’s driven by consistent quality, recognizable formulas, and dependable results.

Why People Choose Jergens

  • Deep hydration for dry and very dry skin

  • Affordable and easy to find

  • Practical everyday formulas

  • Light scents suitable for sensitive noses

  • Simple, effective moisturization

Why People Choose Hempz

  • Plant-based ingredients with clean-beauty appeal

  • 100% pure hemp seed oil as the star ingredient

  • Lightweight, non-greasy application

  • Bold, indulgent fragrances

  • Vegan, cruelty-free formulas

Both brands solve the same problem—hydration—but in two very different ways.

Shop Affinati Body Lotions

Ingredient Breakdown: What’s Inside Each Lotion?

Jergens Key Ingredients

  • Glycerin (powerful humectant that draws in moisture)

  • Petrolatum & Mineral Oil (occlusives that lock in hydration)

  • Vitamin E

  • Niacinamide (in select variants)

  • Shea Butter

  • Lactic Acid (gentle exfoliation in certain formulas)

Benefits of Jergens Ingredients

  • Excellent for dry or cracked skin

  • Creates a long-lasting moisture barrier

  • Smooths texture and softens rough areas

  • Helps repair skin over time

Drawbacks

  • Heavier formula compared to plant-oil lotions

  • Some people may prefer to avoid petrolatum

  • Not considered a clean-beauty formula

Hempz Key Ingredients

  • 100% pure hemp seed oil (rich in omega fatty acids)

  • Shea butter

  • Aloe vera

  • Chamomile

  • Vitamins A, C, & E

  • Plant oils like coconut, jojoba, sunflower

  • Fruit extracts depending on scent family

Benefits of Hempz Ingredients

  • Lightweight hydration with a silky finish

  • Smooth, glowing skin without heaviness

  • Supports skin barrier with omega-rich hemp oil

  • Clean, vegan, plant-based

  • Spa-like fragrance experience

Drawbacks

  • Higher price point

  • Not hydrating enough for extremely dry skin

  • Strong scents may irritate very sensitive skin

Hydration Power: Deep Moisture vs Lightweight Nourishment

Hydration is the #1 reason most shoppers choose these lotions—and it’s where the brands differ the most.

Jergens Hydration

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5 for dry skin)

Jergens excels at:

  • Repairing dry, rough, flaky skin

  • Delivering long-lasting moisture

  • Protecting the skin barrier

  • Providing relief in cold or dry climates

Its thicker formula makes it perfect for nighttime or winter routines.

Hempz Hydration

⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 for normal to dry skin)

Hempz excels at:

  • Lightweight, refreshing hydration

  • Daily use without greasiness

  • Quick absorption for busy routines

  • Soft, silky, glowy skin

It’s the ideal daytime lotion or year-round choice for people with normal skin.

Texture & Absorption: How Each Lotion Feels

Jergens Texture

  • Creamy and rich

  • Slightly heavier

  • Takes a bit longer to fully absorb

  • Creates a protective shield

Best used:

  • Before bed

  • After showering

  • In cold weather

  • For chronic dryness

Hempz Texture

  • Silky and lightweight

  • Fast-absorbing

  • Non-sticky

  • Leaves a soft finish

Best used:

  • In the morning

  • Before going out

  • In warm climates

  • After workouts

Scent Comparison: Subtle vs Bold Fragrance Profiles

Jergens Scents

  • Soft, clean, gentle

  • Classic Cherry Almond

  • Shea Butter

  • Rose, Vanilla, and Light Floral options

Great for:

Hempz Scents

  • Bold, fun, and indulgent

  • Pineapple & Honey Melon

  • Vanilla Plum

  • Coconut & Watermelon

  • Sandalwood & Apple Blossom

  • Seasonal limited-edition scents

Great for:

  • Fragrance lovers

  • People who want compliments on scent

  • Fans of tropical or sweet profiles

This scent divide is timeless—Hempz will always be the more aromatic choice.

Which Lotion Works Best for Your Skin Type?

Dry or Very Dry Skin

Winner: Jergens
Deep, lasting hydration that repairs dryness.

Normal Skin

Winner: Hempz or Jergens
Both work; preference depends on texture.

Oily or Acne-Prone Skin

Winner: Hempz
Lighter formula absorbs quickly without clogging pores.

Sensitive Skin

Winner: Jergens (Fragrance-Free)
Less scent = less irritation.

Combination Skin

Morning: Hempz
Night: Jergens

This routine works forever—it’s evergreen and reliable.

Clean Beauty Standards: A Clear Brand Divide

Jergens

  • Not marketed as clean beauty

  • Not vegan

  • Uses traditional moisturizers like mineral oil

Hempz

  • 100% vegan

  • Plant-based formulas

  • Popular among natural skincare lovers

  • Aligned with long-term ingredient transparency trends

If clean beauty continues trending upward, Hempz will always win this category.

Long-Term Skin Benefits: What Happens After 30+ Days

Jergens Long-Term Benefits

  • Stronger moisture barrier

  • Smoother, softer texture

  • Reduced flakiness

  • Hydrated, healthier-looking skin

Especially noticeable on:

  • Legs

  • Elbows

  • Hands

  • Dermatitis-prone areas

Hempz Long-Term Benefits

  • Improved elasticity

  • Silky, glowy skin

  • Balanced hydration level

  • Non-greasy softness

Perfect for:

  • Daily maintenance

  • Glow lovers

  • Warm-climate users

Price Comparison: Budget vs Premium

Jergens

  • Usually $5–$9

  • Widely accessible

Hempz

  • Usually $16–$26

  • Considered mid-range premium

Conclusion:
Jergens wins for affordability.
Hempz wins for clean premium feel.

Longevity Test: How Long Does Each Lotion Last on Skin?

Jergens

  • Hydration lasts 10–12 hours

  • Ideal for dry climates

Hempz

  • Hydration lasts 4–6 hours

  • Ideal for warm climates or quick applications

Scent Longevity

Jergens

  • Light scent fades fast (1–2 hours)

Hempz

  • Strong scents linger (4–6 hours)

This pattern remains consistent across all formulas.

Breakout Risk: Which Lotion Is Safer for Acne-Prone Skin?

Jergens

  • Heavy texture may clog pores for some

  • Use fragrance-free for sensitive skin

Hempz

  • Lightweight plant oils rarely cause breakouts

  • Safer for chest, neck, and shoulders

Packaging & Aesthetic Appeal

Jergens

  • Classic, simple bottles

  • Clean, medical, practical look

Hempz

  • Colorful, trendy, aesthetic

  • Feels more like a spa brand

Pros and Cons Overview

⭐ Jergens Pros

  • Intense hydration

  • Best for dry or very dry skin

  • Affordable

  • Long-lasting moisture

  • Great nighttime lotion

❌ Jergens Cons

  • Heavy for some

  • Not “clean beauty”

  • Mild scents only

⭐ Hempz Pros

  • Plant-based

  • Lightweight

  • Great scents

  • Vegan and clean

  • Fast absorption

❌ Hempz Cons

  • More expensive

  • Not for severe dryness

  • Strong scents may irritate

Final Verdict: Jergens vs Hempz

Both lotions are excellent—but for different reasons.

Choose Jergens if you want:

  • Deep, intense moisturization

  • Relief for dry or flaky skin

  • Affordable daily hydration

  • Long-lasting moisture

Choose Hempz if you want:

  • Lightweight feel

  • Vegan, plant-based formulas

  • Strong, delicious scents

  • A spa-like lotion experience

Best Overall Strategy:

  • Use Hempz in the morning for glow and fast absorption

  • Use Jergens at night for deep hydration and repair

This pairing works year-round and gives you the best of both worlds.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which lotion is better overall?

Neither is universally better—they serve different purposes. Jergens for deep hydration, Hempz for lightweight moisture and scent.

2. Which lotion is better for dry skin?

Jergens.

3. Which lotion is better for oily skin?

Hempz.

4. Does Hempz smell stronger?

Yes. Hempz is known for bold, long-lasting scents.

5. Is Hempz natural?

Yes, it uses plant oils and vegan formulas.

6. Is Jergens good for sensitive skin?

Yes, especially fragrance-free versions.

7. Which lasts longer on the skin?

Jergens' moisture lasts longer, but Hempz scents last longer.

Read More:

1. Why You Shouldn’t Buy Goose Creek Candles | Better Alternatives Explained

2. All About Bath & Body Works Lotion – Scents, Hydration & Modern Clean Alternatives

3. Best Vanilla Body Lotion | Affinati French Vanilla & More

Back to blog

Affinati Collections