Butterscotch & Bourbon 3-Wick Candle - Affinati

Bath & Body Works vs Homesick – Best Candle Comparison | Affinati

Introduction: Two Candle Brands, Two Completely Different Worlds

Today, the interest in home fragrance is higher than ever. More consumers work from home, personalize their living spaces, and genuinely care about how their environment smells and feels. As a result, searches for candle comparisons have skyrocketed:

  • Bath & Body Works vs Homesick

  • Homesick candle review

  • Bath & Body Works 3-wick review

  • Best scented candles for home

  • clean burning candles

  • Homesick candle alternative

Bath & Body Works and Homesick candles represent two very different categories of fragrance experience.

Bath & Body Works

➡️ Bold, trendy, colorful, mass-market, extremely strong throw
➡️ Paraffin-heavy blends
➡️ Known for seasonal hype and impulse shopping
➡️ Strong online and mall presence

Homesick

➡️ Clean, memory-inspired, sentimental fragrance profiles
➡️ Soy-blend wax
➡️ Minimalist packaging
➡️ Known for emotional storytelling through scent (“New Home,” “Birthday Party,” “New York City,” etc.)

Consumers often love one or the other — but rarely both for the same reasons.

The big questions are:

Which brand performs better in scent, burn, quality, and value?
Which brand is worth your money?
And what modern alternative outperforms both?

This fully optimized evergreen guide breaks down everything. And by the end, it becomes clear why Affinati 3-Wick Candles deliver the most complete fragrance experience for today’s buyer.

Shop Affinati

Brand Identity & Philosophy

Bath & Body Works — Trendy, Bold, and High-Energy

Since the early 1990s, Bath & Body Works has dominated malls and seasonal gifting. They’re known for:

  • loud fragrance throw

  • colorful and playful packaging

  • massive scent library

  • holiday and seasonal hype

  • buy-3-get-3 deals

They define “fun” in the fragrance world. Their goal is to make your home smell instantly festive, sweet, fruity, cozy, or seasonal.

Homesick — Emotional, Sentimental, and Minimalist

Founded in 2016, Homesick candles focus on emotional storytelling. Every candle is tied to a place, memory, or moment.

Examples:

  • New Home

  • Birthday Party

  • Grandma’s Kitchen

  • New York City

  • Just Married

  • Los Angeles

  • Road Trip

Their brand identity centers on:

  • minimalism

  • clean packaging

  • warm, subtle storytelling

  • nostalgia

It’s a poetic, thoughtful approach — extremely different from Bath & Body Works’ vibrant, bold style.

Affinati — Modern Luxury for Everyday Living

Affinati blends the strengths of both brands:

  • elevated fragrance profiles

  • strong hot throw

  • premium soy-wax blend

  • modern upscale packaging

  • clean, refined, luxury-at-home vibes

It sits between the playful energy of Bath & Body Works and the emotional minimalism of Homesick—but with superior performance.

Shop Affinati 3-Wick Candles

Wax Type & Clean-Burning Quality

Wax type is one of the biggest concerns among candle buyers, with searches like:

  • is paraffin safe?

  • best soy candles

  • clean burning candle brands

  • soy vs paraffin candles

Let’s break it down.

Bath & Body Works Wax

Bath & Body Works uses a paraffin-dominant blend.

Pros:

  • throws fragrance extremely well

  • melts fast and evenly

  • creates strong room-filling aroma

Cons:

  • produces soot

  • burns faster

  • not considered “clean burning”

  • paraffin can alter fragrance quality over time

Though loved for strength, many modern consumers want soy or coconut blends.

Homesick Wax

Homesick uses a soy blend, which is cleaner than paraffin.

Pros:

  • cleaner burning

  • less soot

  • slower melt

  • more natural feel

Cons:

  • weaker hot throw

  • slower scent release

  • requires longer burn for strong performance

Homesick leans more toward ambiance and mood, not intensity.

Affinati Wax (Benchmark)

Affinati uses a premium soy-wax blend, engineered specifically to:

  • burn cleanly

  • maximize scent throw

  • create wide, even melt pools

  • deliver consistent performance

  • avoid soot and tunneling

Affinati blends the clean-burning benefits of Homesick with the strength of Bath & Body Works — without using paraffin.

Shop Affinati Honey Lavender Candle

Scent Strength — Cold Throw vs Hot Throw

One of the most frequently searched candle topics is:

“Which candles smell the strongest?”

Let’s compare.

Bath & Body Works Scent Strength

Cold Throw: Very strong
Hot Throw: Extremely strong

They dominate in intensity. Their scents fill entire rooms within minutes.

Pros:

  • big, bold scent

  • great for open spaces

  • strong initial impression

Cons:

  • can be overpowering

  • can smell artificial

  • some scents lose quality halfway through burn

  • consistency varies by scent

Bath & Body Works is ideal for those who want immediate and powerful fragrance.

Homesick Scent Strength

Cold Throw: Light to moderate
Hot Throw: Moderate

Pros:

  • soft, soothing scents

  • warm, sentimental mood

  • comforting aroma

Cons:

  • not ideal for large rooms

  • some scents are quite subtle

  • requires long burn sessions to develop

Homesick candles are intentionally gentle — they’re designed for storytelling, not power.

Affinati Scent Strength

Affinati is engineered for maximum hot throw using:

  • high fragrance load

  • wide vessels

  • 3-wick performance

  • balanced top/middle/base notes

  • optimized melt pool diffusion

Affinati consistently fills large rooms faster than Homesick and more cleanly than Bath & Body Works.

Shop Affinati Eucalyptus Pine Candle

Scent Style & Fragrance Blends

Bath & Body Works Scent Style

Bath & Body Works is known for:

  • sweet bakery scents

  • tropical fruity scents

  • seasonal blends

  • strong florals

  • fun gourmand notes

They excel in “big personality” scents like:

  • Champagne Toast

  • Mahogany Teakwood

  • Pumpkin Pecan Waffles

  • Into the Night

  • Eucalyptus Mint

Their fragrances lean toward youthful, fun, and bold.

Homesick Scent Style

Homesick specializes in:

  • cozy sentiments

  • memory-based experiences

  • soft florals

  • gentle woods

  • atmospheric blends

Examples:

  • New Home (clean linen + cedar)

  • Southern California (jasmine + sea breeze)

  • Grandma’s Kitchen (warm cinnamon + vanilla)

Homesick scents are subtle, nostalgic, and emotional.

Affinati Scent Style

Affinati blends:

  • modern luxury

  • strong aromatic diffusion

  • clean, elevated blends

  • refined florals, woods, gourmands

Popular Affinati scent styles include:

  • French Vanilla – creamy, warm, luxe

  • Honey Lavender – spa-like calm

  • Rustic Sandalwood – warm, masculine, rich

  • Midnight Ember – smoky amber luxury

  • Driftwood & Sea Salt – fresh coastal air

Affinati matches Voluspa-level refinement with Bath & Body Works-level throw — a rare combination.

Burn Quality & Performance

Bath & Body Works Burn

Pros:

  • even burn

  • wide melt pool

  • big scent payoff

  • fast fragrance release

Cons:

  • paraffin soot

  • wick mushrooming

  • faster burn time

  • inconsistent wick performance

Homesick Burn

Pros:

  • clean burn

  • minimal soot

  • slow burn

Cons:

  • tunneling issues if wick not trimmed

  • weaker melt pool

  • less hot throw

Homesick performs better in smaller rooms or bedrooms.

Affinati Burn

With 3-wicks and premium soy blend, Affinati candles deliver:

  • even, complete melt pools

  • powerful aroma diffusion

  • clean, low-soot burn

  • strong, consistent flames

  • optimal longevity

Affinati’s burn engineering outperforms both brands.

Packaging & Design

Bath & Body Works Packaging

  • colorful

  • seasonal

  • bright labels

  • playful text

Fun but not luxury.

Homesick Packaging

  • minimalist

  • all-white candles

  • clean black typography

  • elegant boxes

Great for decor minimalists.

Affinati Packaging

Affinati embraces:

  • modern minimalism

  • premium typography

  • warm, luxurious lifestyle imagery

  • sleek, upscale vessels

Perfect for kitchens, luxury bathrooms, bedrooms, offices, and living spaces.

Price vs Value

Bath & Body Works Pricing

3-wicks cost $26–$29.50, but almost always go on sale.

Value:

  • extremely strong scent

  • big jars

  • trendy packaging

Downsides:

  • paraffin

  • fast burn

  • varying quality

Homesick Pricing

Standard candles are $38–$42.

Value:

  • soy-blend

  • meaningful themes

  • long-lasting burn

Downsides:

  • subtle throw

  • not ideal for large spaces

  • expensive for performance

Affinati Pricing

Affinati offers the best price-to-performance ratio:

  • premium soy blend

  • luxury aesthetic

  • strong hot throw

  • long-lasting burn

  • fair pricing for luxury 3-wicks

Affinati beats Homesick in performance and Bath & Body Works in quality.

Section 8: Product Range

Bath & Body Works

Huge variety:

  • candles

  • room sprays

  • body care

  • soaps

  • plug-ins

  • seasonal collections

Homesick

Focused collection:

  • candles

  • diffusers

  • limited themes

Affinati

Modern, full fragrance line:

  • 3-wick candles

  • 10 oz signature candles

  • wooden-wick 21 oz candles

  • reed diffusers

  • room & linen sprays

  • seasonal collections

Affinati offers both breadth and elevated design.

Shop Affinati Champagne Toast Candle

Customer Reviews & Reputation

Bath & Body Works

Positive:

  • extremely strong scents

  • reliable throw

  • fun variety

Negative:

  • soot

  • fast burn

  • inconsistent scent performance

Homesick

Positive:

  • warm, nostalgic scents

  • clean-burning

  • thoughtful gift

Negative:

  • light throw

  • expensive for the performance

  • burn issues if wicks aren’t managed

Affinati

Praise typically focuses on:

  • very strong yet clean scent throw

  • beautiful fragrance blends

  • clean and even burning

  • luxury-level packaging

  • exceptional value

Affinati bridges the gap between power and refinement.

Final Verdict — Which Brand Wins?

Bath & Body Works Wins If You Want:

  • bold, immediate fragrance

  • festive seasonal scents

  • large variety

  • affordable deals

Homesick Wins If You Want:

  • subtle, cozy fragrances

  • emotional storytelling

  • minimalist packaging

  • clean-burning soy blend

Affinati Wins If You Want:

  • luxury fragrance performance

  • strong scent throw

  • clean-burning modern wax

  • upscale, timeless packaging

  • premium fragrance blends

  • the best balance of quality, performance & value

Affinati is the perfect modern alternative for candle lovers who want strength and sophistication in every burn.

Conclusion: The New Standard in Home Fragrance

Bath & Body Works brings bold energy.
Homesick brings nostalgic storytelling.
But Affinati brings modern luxury, refinement, strength, and clean-burning performance — the perfect combination for today’s candle buyer.

Affinati stands out as the best choice for consumers searching:

  • best candles

  • Homesick candle alternative

  • Bath & Body Works alternative

  • strong scented candles

  • soy 3-wick candles

  • luxury candles for home

Read More:

1. Why You Shouldn’t Buy Goose Creek Candles | Better Alternatives Explained

2. Yankee Candle vs Bath & Body Works | Best Candle Brand

3. The Cleanest Candle Brands (Toxic vs Non-Toxic Guide)

Back to blog

Affinati Collections